CrazyEgg vs Mouseflow vs SessionStack: A Definitive Comparison [June 2023]

CrazyEgg vs Mouseflow vs SessionStack: A Definitive Comparison [June 2023]

Mihael Cacic

Jul 6, 2023 • 13 min read

CrazyEgg vs Mouseflow vs SessionStack: Definitive Comparison

I used and tested both CrazyEgg and Mouseflow on my SaaS platform and website and in this article, I’ll highlight the differences that stood out to me the most:

CrazyEgg is an excellent tool if you’re looking to optimize user experience with heatmaps and customer surveys. I imagine e-commerce sites would gain the most out of it to improve return visitors’ experience. However, it doesn’t offer any solutions to analyze your customer journey and its session replay feature is painfully slow.

Meanwhile, Mouseflow is built for optimizing conversions by understanding the exact elements users interact with (dynamic heatmaps) and analyzing conversion elements (form analytics). Its strengths are similar to CrazyEgg’s but focused on different use cases, while its weakness is the same: session replay features.

Since both tools lack great session replay for understanding exact user behavior, I included SessionStack in this comparison. It offers detailed error logging, easy-to-use session replay, sitewide user interaction tracking, and real-time co-browsing tools which makes it ideal for product designers, developers, and customer support teams looking to quickly troubleshoot and resolve issues with their SaaS platforms and web apps.

I’ll compare CrazyEgg vs Mouseflow vs SessionStack in five key areas:

  1. Heatmaps
  2. Co-browsing
  3. Session replay
  4. Customer journey analysis
  5. Error logs

I also talk about site loading speed impact and integrations to give you a more complete picture in the overview table below:

CrazyEgg Mouseflow SessionStack
Price
⭐⭐⭐
30-day free trial on all plans. Paid plans start at $29/mo for 30,000 page views.
⭐⭐
14-day free trial after which you can opt for the free plan. Paid subscriptions starting at $39/mo for 5,000 sessions.
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
SessionStack’s pricing is currently in revision.*
Session Replay
⭐⭐
Session replay has a long load time, difficult-to-use UI, and no error log.    
⭐⭐⭐
Basic session replay features without an activity or error log. 
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Session replay supports features like filters, search bar, activity log, and an error logging tool.
Co-browsing

Doesn’t support live session replay or co-browsing.

Doesn’t support live session replay or co-browsing.
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Co-browsing features with <1-sec latency and interactive tools like pointer, pen, and control takeover.
AI Integration


No AI capabilities


No AI capabilities

🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
AI-augmented session replays. Saves time with optimization recommendations and session summaries.

Heatmaps
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Offers five unique heatmaps including Overlay and Confetti reports. Also supports visual side-by-side comparison. 
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Click, scroll, & move maps + live heatmaps providing a realistic representation of dynamic elements (only available for desktop sessions).
⭐⭐⭐
Provides site-wide click tracking with information like dead clicks and rage clicks about each page element.
Customer Journey Analysis
⭐⭐
Doesn’t support funnel tracking. Instead, provides surveys to collect direct customer feedback and gauge NPS. 
⭐⭐⭐
Ignores key user behaviors like skipped pages, order of visits, and conversions.
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Supports funnels with up to four events and no step limit. Maps basic user journeys to identify problematic site elements.
Site Speed Impact
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The JavaScript is asynchronous and doesn’t affect site speed or page load times. 
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Average 68ms page speed impact across the web. Light JavaScript — loads without blocking the browser thread.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Extremely lightweight JavaScript. Doesn’t block main thread execution.
Integrations
⭐⭐⭐
20+ native integrations & 9 third-party integrations
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
127 native integrations + Mouseflow API
⭐⭐⭐
14 native integrations + SessionStack API 
G2 Reviews
4.2 rating from 104 reviews 4.6 Rating from 452 reviews 4.9 Rating from 63 reviews
Used By
CNET, Etsy, Yahoo, Intuit Mint, Zendesk Verizon, Vodafone, Philips, Etihad Kraken, Bazaarvoice, Imagine.ai, Mend, Texas.gov
Best For
Collecting visitor feedback and broad interaction data to optimize your user experience. Visualizing user interactions with page elements and optimizing forms. Identifying user frustration points with your app or website.
30-day free trial
(credit card required)
14-day free trial
(no card required)
Book a demo

SessionStack is being reshaped to meet the growing demands of its existing and future customers. The team is laser-focused on helping e-commerce businesses streamline their conversion rate optimization efforts for faster revenue growth. This is done through an industry-first AI capability – SessionStackAI, which is based on the rich session data the platform is already built to collect.

 

As part of the ongoing change, SessionStackAI is currently offered only as a paid pilot service with a 21-day free trial. To find out how SessionStackAI can help optimize your e-store with no effort, book a demo today 👉

What is CrazyEgg?
“Speak to your customers directly” 🧑‍🏫

In the early-2000s, as internet adoption grew, Asmee Shah and John Butler noticed a very bad trend: most websites offered confusing user experiences. So, in 2006, they started CrazyEgg to provide website owners with actionable insights to improve their online experience.

After pioneering one of the first heatmap technologies, CrazyEgg has added features that help improve your complete online customer experience from browser and mobile experiences to web apps. Tools like the Overlay and Confetti report provide a unique look into how users interact with each element of your webpage. You also have access to unlimited A/B tests and Surveys, letting you experiment with different layouts and optimize your website with direct feedback from your audience. This mix of tools will help you quickly understand what your customers like despite its limiting session recording feature.

E-commerce and utility sites will get the best out of CrazyEgg with direct customer feedback, heatmaps, and A/B tests. That’s reflected in their customer profile which includes companies like CNET, Etsy, and Yahoo.

What is Mouseflow?
“Map the customer’s mouse flow” ✨🗺️✨

Since opening its doors in 2009, Mouseflow has helped decision-makers in over 125,000 organizations improve their conversion rate by helping them understand ‘why’ users perform specific actions.    

Mouseflow does this by offering tools like Live Heatmaps, which visualize user interactions on dynamic web page elements like drop-down menus and revolution sliders. You also get access to Form Analytics to track how users find and interact with your web forms. Although its session replay feature is pretty bare-boned, it’s extremely lightweight and doesn’t affect your site speed.   

Funnel marketers and landing-page-reliant sites will get the most out of Mouseflow’s dynamic heatmaps and form analytics. That’s why corporate brands like Verizon, Vodafone, Philips, and Etihad use it.

What is SessionStack?
Create the perfect customer experience” ⭐💻⭐

Alexander Zlatkov left his job as a software engineer at Progress in 2016 to create SessionStack: a tool that allowed companies to understand exactly how users interact with their online apps. 

SessionStack does this by providing advanced session replay features that offer more value than the others in the market, eventually earning them G2’s “session replay category leader” award in 2023. It essentially lets you join a user’s session in real time by maintaining a latency of under one second. This helped them build a live session support tool called co-browsing. Co-browsing lets you interact with users during a session and take control of their session without installing any third-party software. If you can’t be present in real-time, you can use its advanced error logging and user segmentation tools to identify the most important issues plaguing your website.

Businesses like Kraken.com, Bazaarvoice, and Imagine.ai trust SessionStack because of the tool’s flexibility which caters to most internal teams, including product management, development, and customer support teams.

CrazyEgg vs Mouseflow vs SessionStack: Session Replay

CrazyEgg is great for user segmentation. Mouseflow is ideal for customer journey analysis. SessionStack makes troubleshooting easier. 

CrazyEgg Mouseflow SessionStack
⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Session Replay is an analytics feature that records user sessions on your website, capturing interactions like clicks, mouse movements, scrolls, and page navigation. It’s crucial for understanding user behavior and optimizing the customer experience. 

In this section, we will compare the tool’s session replay capabilities on five criteria:

  1. UI/UX design
  2. User segmentation
  3. Live sessions
  4. Co-browsing
  5. Error logs

UI/UX design
Mouseflow is too basic, SessionStack is very user-friendly, and CrazyEgg has long load times and a clunky UI.

Mouseflow has a simple user interface. I’d say it keeps it too simple by not including an activity or error log.

Instead, it uses different colors to highlight actions (1)  like mouse movements, clicks, interactions, etc. Important events are marked using icons (2). For example, ⚠️ for errors and ⚡ for rage clicks, as in the screenshot below. It doesn’t have a console feature with more information about events like SessionStack and CrazyEgg.

CrazyEgg has a very simple design with the video player on the left and the event log on the right. You can jump to an event by simply clicking on its corresponding entry in the event log or on the video player bar. CrazyEgg groups each session by users, making user segmentation and understanding user behavior easier. 

But, there are some kinks that I noticed while I was using the tool. The most frustrating one is the long load time (~20 seconds). Also, the console blocks the video player when you open it, restricting your view of the session replay – something you won’t see with SessionStack.

SessionStack’s session replay tool is more user-friendly. It has a video player on the right and an action log (1) on the left-hand side of the screen. As the video plays, the timestamp corresponding to each event is highlighted in the activity log, making it easier to track events as they occur. You can get more information on each event by clicking on the drop-down arrow.

You will also find the console (2) below the video player providing detailed logs on each action, making troubleshooting easier. You can find the exact action you’re looking for using the filters (3).

AI-Augmented Session Replays
SessionStack’s session replays, backed by AI, provide concise session breakdowns and optimization advice.

You’ll notice a “Get Summary” option in the left toolbar of the session recording. Clicking this will trigger the tool’s AI assistant to provide a summary of the entire session recording. This summary consists of three segments:

  • Session breakdown: A brief account of the user’s activities during the session.
  • Significant happenings: A ten-item list of key events from the session.
  • Enhancement recommendations: Suggestions for user journey optimization based on the events from the session.
SessionStackAI

User Segmentation
All three support user segmentation. SessionStack offers the most relevant options, Mouseflow lets you create custom tags and variables, while CrazyEgg segments users automatically. 

EDITOR’S NOTE: What is user segmentation?

User segmentation (or ‘audience segmentation) is the process of categorizing your users based on their demographic, behavior, interactions, and type (new vs returning). Segmenting users is a great way to identify how you can improve your website’s or app’s UI/UX to maximize conversions.

CrazyEgg automatically segments your visitors by assigning each one a unique user ID. Sessions are grouped based on these unique IDs. You can go a step further by filtering your audience according to visitor details, session information, and ad campaign. You can also create up to five custom variables to track trends specific to your business.

Mouseflow provides basic user segmentation filters like device type, session length, location, user action, etc. Although it doesn’t support user profiles, it lets you analyze specific trends by creating custom variables and tags for ad campaigns or events like order amounts, abandoned carts, etc. 

SessionStack keeps things very simple. It simplifies user behavior analysis by providing filters covering important segmentation criteria like users, sessions, and events. If you are looking for something different, you can create and save custom user segments that align with your specific needs. 

Live Sessions & Co-Browsing
Mouseflow and CrazyEgg don’t offer live sessions, while SessionStack does and provides a real-time support tool called co-browsing.

EDITOR’S NOTE: What are live sessions?

Live sessions give you a real-time view of how users interact with your website. It’s a great tool for product, development, and customer support teams looking to resolve customer issues when they are raised.

SessionStack is the only platform offering truly real-time live sessions with a latency of less than one second. Using this, they were able to develop co-browsing – a real-time customer support tool.

Co-browsing lets customer support teams and account managers guide users in real time without installing any plug-ins, software, or add-ons. You get access to three tools in co-browsing mode:

  • A pointer to highlight elements on the screen without interacting with the page elements.
  • A pen to add annotations on your user’s screen.
  • Control takeover which gives you permission to perform actions on the user’s behalf from your browser.

SessionStack protects a user’s privacy by hiding sensitive information like passwords, credit card details, etc. Most of the information is hidden by default. But you can also set your own parameters. 

NOTE: Co-browsing is not the same as screen sharing where you can access the user’s computer. Co-browsing only allows access to the shared tab and nothing else. You can read more about co-browsing here.    

Winner: SessionStack. Both customer support and product development teams will appreciate its real-time co-browsing feature and faster load times.

CrazyEgg vs Mouseflow vs SessionStack: Heatmaps   

CrazyEgg measures the performance of clickable elements, Mouseflow tracks the performance of dynamic elements, while SessionStack helps you identify website issues more easily.

CrazyEgg Mouseflow SessionStack
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐

Heatmaps visually represent visitor interactions on your website by highlighting areas that get the most clicks, movements, and scrolls. They can be used to identify the elements users interact with the most, receive the most attention, and frustrate the user.

CrazyEgg lets you deep-dive into each page element.

CrazyEgg has five different heatmaps to understand user interactions.

  1. Heatmap reports are simple ‘click’ heatmaps to see which parts of the website are getting the most attention.
  2. Scrollmap reports to illustrate how far visitors scroll on your most important web pages.
  3. List report displays every interaction in a tabulated format.
  4. Overlay reports measure the performance of your clickable elements individually.
  5. Confetti map is just a more detailed heatmap report with metrics to assess on-page behavior.

It offers basic filters like date ranges, device types, etc. You can also compare sessions side-by-side, making it great for evaluating A/B test performances.

Mouseflow offers live heatmaps.

Apart from click, scroll, and movement heatmaps, Mouseflow offers dynamic heatmaps to track interaction with dynamic elements like drop-downs, revolution sliders, parallax scrolling, etc. It overlays the data directly on the website to show you exactly how users interact with your website – a feature missing in CrazyEgg.

SessionStack offers insights into the most relevant user interactions.

SessionStack doesn’t offer visual heatmaps. Instead, it provides a sitewide overview of essential user actions and problematic events like:

  • Most clicked elements (1)
  • Elements with the most ‘dead clicks’ (2)
  • Elements with the most ‘rage clicks’ (3)

It simplifies troubleshooting by compiling the most interacted-with elements and frustration signals in one space — cutting down on time spent analyzing the webpage.

Winner: Mouseflow. Along with click, scroll, and mouse movement heatmaps, it offers live heatmaps to help you visualize how users interact with dynamic page elements. You also get access to filters to derive some granular insights.

CrazyEgg vs Mouseflow vs SessionStack: Customer Journey Analysis

Mouseflow and SessionStack have funnel analytic tools, while CrazyEgg lets you create and publish surveys.

CrazyEgg Mouseflow SessionStack
⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Customer journey refers to how users navigate your website and interact with content (webpages, blogs, articles, social media posts, etc). You can track the customer journey using funnels (a step-by-step process of how you think visitors interact with your website). Funnels help you understand visitor behavior and let you segment them according to their interactions.

CrazyEgg lets you create unlimited surveys to understand your customer preferences.

CrazyEgg doesn’t have a funnel analytics tool. But you can use its survey tool to get feedback directly from your visitors, rate their website experience, and gauge your net promoter score (NPS).

With unlimited storage for surveys, you have the freedom to create as many surveys as you like. You get access to two layout types: pop-up and external link. You can also use custom settings and logic to create a dynamic quiz that asks your visitors only relevant questions while minimizing drop-off. 

Mouseflow can track funnels but ignores important customer interaction patterns.

Mouseflow combines historical and real-time data to provide insights on increasing your conversion rate. But, Mouseflow’s funnel analysis tool ignores some important information:

  1. It doesn’t consider the order in which a user goes through the funnel as long as the user visits all the pages in the funnel.
  2. Users can visit any number of pages while moving through the funnel. 
  3. Users who don’t visit every page in the conversion funnel are not counted.

Without this information, you won’t get all the insights you need to make an informed decision. 

SessionStack tracks important event types for a flawless customer journey.

SessionStack lets you create funnels with unlimited steps. It also provides a more complete solution compared to Mouseflow by including users who complete the conversion step. You can track two important event types: ‘dead clicks’ and ‘rage clicks’. Understanding when and where these events occur can help you resolve them and create a smoother customer journey.

Winner: SessionStack because it lets you create funnels with unlimited steps and addresses the issues with Mouseflow. It’s a great tool for marketing teams looking to optimize their website conversions.

CrazyEgg vs Mouseflow vs SessionStack: Error Logs

Mouseflow has basic error-logging features, while SessionStack and CrazyEgg have dedicated error-logging pages.

Mouseflow doesn’t have a dedicated errors page. 

Mouseflow automatically highlights Javascript errors in the session replay tool with a ⚠️ icon (shown below). You can hover over the icon to view more information about the error but there is no option available to share this option with your team like you can with SessionStack and CrazyEgg. 

CrazyEgg doesn’t tell you what the error is.

CrazyEgg also has a dedicated error page similar to SessionStack. It automatically detects and lists errors along with important debugging details like full stack trace, visitor information, and application version. Once it’s resolved, you can update its status so your team knows the error has been dealt with. But, unlike SessionStack, CrazyEgg can’t tell you what the exact error is.

SessionStack’s console makes troubleshooting faster with detailed error information.

SessionStack has a dedicated errors page that provides a comprehensive overview of each error with important debugging information (1). You can also view the related session recording (2) to make troubleshooting easier. 

It also highlights errors in the session replay tool (1), making it easier for you to troubleshoot errors. You can use filters to identify specific errors (rage clicks, dead clicks, u-turns, etc.) during a session – something CrazyEgg’s error log doesn’t have. You also access the console feature (2) to get more information about each error. 

Winner: SessionStack makes troubleshooting errors faster with its dedicated error page. Development teams will benefit from its great error-tracking and logging features.

CrazyEgg vs Mouseflow vs SessionStack: Pros & Cons

CrazyEgg ProsCrazyEgg Cons
✅ 30-day free trial on any plan ❌ Difficult-to-use session replay UI
✅ Comprehensive heatmaps❌ Longer load times for session replay
✅ Unlimited surveys❌ Doesn’t support live sessions or co-browsing
✅ Dedicated error logging page❌ No funnel analytics
❌ Pricing per page view
Mouseflow ProsMouseflow Cons
✅ 14-day free trial❌ Unimpressive session replay features
✅ Dynamic live heatmap tool❌ Doesn’t support live sessions or co-browsing
✅ 127 native integrations❌ Live heatmaps only for desktop sessions
✅ Supports custom tags and variables❌ Limited funnel analytics
❌ Limited free plan
SessionStack ProsSessionStack Cons
✅ Best free plan❌ No annotation in session replay
✅ Affordable pricing plans ❌ Does not have page-specific heatmaps
✅ Lightweight & easy to set up❌ Can’t track every user event with funnels
✅ Live sessions & co-browsing
✅ Intuitive session replays
✅ Dedicated error tracking page

Final Verdict: CrazyEgg vs Mouseflow vs SessionStack

CrazyEggMouseflowSessionStack
Best for:
Optimizing the user experience on e-commerce and utility sites by collecting direct feedback and visualizing user actions.
Best for:
Optimizing conversions on corporate websites and funnels with form analytics and dynamic heatmaps.
Best for:
Web apps and SaaS platforms that need in-depth user interaction insights and tools for live user assistance.

CrazyEgg’s heatmaps and survey features make it best for collecting user feedback and gaining user interaction insights with multiple heatmaps. Mouseflow’s dynamic heatmaps and form analytics features make it perfect for optimizing conversion elements. Finally, SessionStack’s advanced session replay features, real-time co-browsing, and error logging dashboard allow customer support teams, product designers, and developers to quickly identify and solve critical issues as they appear.

Use CrazyEgg if:

  • You want to A/B test various versions of your web pages.
  • You want to visually compare data from multiple sessions.
  • You are looking to collect feedback directly from your website visitors.

Click here to get started with CrazyEgg!

Use Mouseflow if:

  • You want detailed information on user interactions.
  • You want to improve the conversion rate of your forms.
  • You want simple funnel analytics to track how users navigate your website.

Click here to get started with Mouseflow!

Use SessionStack if:

  • You’re looking to quickly troubleshoot and resolve issues and errors.
  • You want to provide real-time, personalized customer support experiences.
  • You are looking for a lightweight tool to track how users use your web app or SaaS platform.

Click here to get started with SessionStack!

See what SessionStackAI can do for your business